Many people may be interested in owning a gold IRA. There are many reasons for this. First, you should escape the volatility of stocks and get extra security.
Second, you should lock in your purchasing power, avoid future inflation, or purchase tangible assets such as property or a fine art collection. However, it is important to be aware that, like any retirement savings vehicle: gold is taxed by the government when you withdraw it from the IRA after retirement.
It is important to note that you may deduct your contribution to your gold IRA if you are self-employed. Since United States tax law imposes a 10% penalty on early distributions, anyone planning on leaving their gold in the IRA until they retire should be cautious. This article is intended to provide a general overview of how a Gold IRA is taxed and what penalties are imposed.
We have done hundreds of hours of research on the best precious metals investment companies for anyone that wants to invest!
Taxation of a Gold IRA in General
The tax treatment of an IRA account may vary depending on the company offering it and which state the company operates in (if it's an investment firm). Still, since all IRAs are subject to U.S laws, certain IRS guidelines must be followed.
The type of tax treatment you receive will depend on what you're doing with the IRA. For example, if you invest in stocks and bonds within your IRA, the gains made on those individual investments are not taxed since they do not come from income.
As a result, your stock or bond buying and selling activity within an IRA is not taxed as long as it's done inside your account. This type of activity is known as "passive activity."
Suppose you are withdrawing money from the IRA for any reason other than to pay for qualified medical expenses or to support yourself during retirement. In that case, it will be treated like any other income, which means that withdrawals will be taxed at your current tax rate. It will also be subject to withholding.
In addition, your employer may be required to withhold taxes from your IRA withdrawal if you are under the age of 59½ and have not yet reached retirement.
Regarding the taxation of your ownership of actual gold bullion inside an IRA account, several factors could affect how you are taxed on it. The first is whether or not the gold is being held for its pure investment or industrial purposes (this would include jewellery). Gold bullion owned for investment would be taxed much lower than gold owned for industrial purposes such as jewellery.
The second factor is classifying your gold as "old" or "new." The IRS defines these terms as follows.
Old
Gold which has been held for more than one year and is at most five years old.
New
Gold that has been held for not more than one year and was acquired after January 18, 2002, whether or not the seller holds a U.S. gold certificate to prove its ownership of the gold (i.e., gold coins).
Concerning the second factor, despite what some companies may tell you, it is possible for gold bought after January 18, 2002, to be classified as "old gold." It may be considered old if it had been owned for more than one year before the sale date and was in your possession for at least five years before that date.
Since the IRS does not require you to submit a receipt with your tax return detailing exactly when you bought your gold bullion or how long you have owned it, it is beneficial to consult with your tax professional before attempting to classify it in your IRA account. This is especially true if you purchased it in the years before 2002.
Under the IRS classification rules, gold bullion would not be considered "old gold" if it was needed for industrial purposes. If you collect gold by melting it down to create new jewelry, then that part of your portfolio would not be considered "old" and would be subject to a lower tax rate than other parts of your portfolio.
It should also be noted that a personal residence is likely not an industrial asset or mine, but the IRS has never addressed this question.
Penalties
The IRS has very few "true" penalties in its tax code. For example, they will take the money back if you do not pay your taxes on time. But there are still several penalties that may be imposed if you violate specific rules or make certain prohibited transactions.
The first category includes early distributions from an IRA and taking distributions for uses other than retirement or to cover medical expenses. These are the situations where a 10% penalty is charged. In addition, these types of withdrawals are taxed at your current tax rate, and your employer may be required to withhold taxes from them.
The second category is more severe and involves the misappropriation of IRA assets by an IRA holder. If you sell or transfer IRA assets to someone else before you retire, the penalty can be as much as 50% of the assets transferred.
Another penalty can be imposed if you convert a traditional IRA to a Roth without paying taxes. The penalty for doing so is 5% for every year you were eligible to defer the taxes on it and did not do so.
The last category addresses prohibited transactions where you purposely try to avoid investment losses for your account or serve yourself personally before retirement. These penalties include as much as 25% of the amount you owe for taxes and a 2% commission for each month that you structure your accounts in a way designed to circumvent the IRS tax code.
The most important thing to remember is that these penalties are not punitive but signals to pay attention and follow the rules like everyone else.
Gold IRA Distribution Methods
There are several ways you can distribute gold bullion inside your IRA. According to IRS regulations, it can be distributed in two methods: regular or single-sum distributions.
Regular Distributions
The distribution is made on a regular schedule, such as once per year on April 15 or January 31. Or it could be made continuously throughout the year. You can opt for a partial distribution or withdraw all of it at once.
Single-Sum Distributions
You may also choose to "take all" the gold bullion you own in your IRA and withdraw it all in one payment. This method is known as a single-sum distribution and applies only to gold because silver, platinum, and palladium do not have their own rules regarding IRA distributions. For example, this method could be helpful if you have enough gold to immediately make monthly distributions to your beneficiaries (in a single lump sum) rather than over ten years.
The IRS states that after-tax distributions are taxable income and must be reported on your tax return. This is true regardless of whether or not you receive the gold bullion directly from the IRA, as long as it is being distributed to you for an IRA purpose.
Depending on how your IRA is structured and whether or not you are subject to a 10% early distribution penalty, your withdrawals will be taxed at your current tax bracket rate. Suppose you are subject to a 5% early distribution penalty and make a traditional IRA withdrawal. In that case, the amount withdrawn will be taxed at the higher rate you pay for ordinary income (not capital gains).
If you are subject to a 10% early distribution penalty, the amount withdrawn will be taxed at your current tax rate, and your employer will withhold any additional tax.
While this is less than ideal, most people can use the regular distributions for their IRA if they are subject to a 10% early withdrawal penalty. There are also some Special Distribution Rules you can use to avoid paying taxes on any or all of the funds withdrawn from your IRA. For example, suppose your account was opened before January 1, 2001, and has not been fully distributed since December 31, 1999 (except for regularly scheduled distributions). In that case, you may preserve all or part of your gold bullion in the account by making a nonqualified "annuity" withdrawal.
Gold IRA Minimum Requirements
Your gold IRA must consist of your gold bullion, which you have not recently acquired, and the money in it cannot be excluded from selling other securities. If you have other investments in your account, only up to 15% of your total assets can come from these investments. A maximum of 10% of your account can be from the employer's stock, up to a limit of $10,000 per year.
If you own more than this amount, you will have to withdraw at least some portion of it for the IRS to consider it a Traditional IRA distribution subject to tax.
You can choose to do the documentation for your IRA distributions when and if you decide to file your taxes. The amount will be reported on a 1099-R form if you receive a lump sum payment.
If you are doing regular distributions and need to change your schedule, it is best to wait until the tax day of your next tax year, as most people will have already filed their taxes by April 15.
Frequent rollovers from one IRA custodian to another may also trigger questions by the IRS, so it is best to keep providers the same. If you are doing regular distributions and need to stop, that can be arranged as well, and you can continue to do normal distributions again when you determine the new amount.
If your account is closed for any reason, it will be reported as an "Early Distributions" amount on your tax return (with a note about why it was taken out). This is also true if your funds are distributed to someone else after you pass away. This data should be reported on Form 4972, Tax on Early Distributions from Retirement Plans.
As with any other IRA distribution, the IRS recommends that you consult a qualified tax professional. As with other forms of IRA distribution, you could be subject to a penalty if you fail to include the amount in your tax return.
To find a qualified professional, go to the IRS website and follow the links for Investment Adviser, Certified Public Accountant, Enrolled Agent, and Tax Preparer.
You will then be presented with a list of approved professionals based on your ZIP code. You are allowed unlimited free consultations to start the search immediately.
FAQs
How do I claim my gold IRA after filing my taxes?
To claim a gold IRA, your gold must be contained in an IRA that is distributed under one of the following methods: regular or single-sum distributions.
What happens when I want to take a contribution from my Gold IRA?
You'll need to speak with a professional to make a new Gold IRA contribution. We provide several options that allow you to either send us your metal or have us pick it up for you.
Will I be taxed on withdrawing from an IRA containing gold?
You will likely have to pay taxes on any amount withdrawn as a part of a traditional IRA distribution. This can include an after-tax distribution from your gold IRA.
Will my accrued benefits be taxable?
You would likely need to include any accrued benefits in your income. For example, suppose you are at retirement age and taking a non-qualified distribution with accrued benefits, such as monthly income payments or an annuity.
In that case, these may come after tax and must be reported on your tax return. If a withdrawal is made under the single-sum rules, the IRS notes that this is considered taxable income and must be reported on your tax return.
Don't forget to checkout our highest recommended precious metals investment companies if you want to move forward with an investment!